The fact may seem paradoxical, but none of the works commissioned from Michelangelo Buonarroti for the decoration of Florence Cathedral are currently preserved inside the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore.
The David and the St. Matthew are in the Accademia Gallery. Only the unfinished and mutilated Pietà Bandini is housed inside the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo, in the Michelangelo Tribuna.
With this article, we will explore the relationship between Buonarroti and the Opera del Duomo to reveal to you how works commissioned from the great artist are located elsewhere or were not created at all.
Yet, the link between the genius and Florence Cathedral is very strong and inescapable. Find out with us: read more and book your visit to Santa Maria del Fiore and the Florence Cathedral monumental complex online.

Bestseller ever
Florence Cathedral: Guided Tour
Discover the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore with our guided tour.
Secure payment
Instant confirmation
Mobile ticket
The orders of the Opera del Duomo
It is preserved in the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo, but the Bandini Pietà was not commissioned in Florence or even sculpted there-Michelangelo had thought of it in Rome for his own funeral monument. It arrived in the Tuscan capital only in the second half of the 1600s, after several changes of ownership.
Instead, the Opera del Duomo of Florence commissioned Michelangelo Buonarroti to make the David and the statues of the 12 apostles. The former was to decorate the exterior of the Cathedral (on one of the buttresses of the apse), while the latter were intended for the interior of Santa Maria del Fiore.
Things, however, went differently than planned. The David, when completed, was moved to Piazza della Signoria as a symbol of the Republic. Of the 12 apostles, only the St. Matthew was sketched by Buonarroti. Here is what happened.
The David

File ID 103634521 | David Michelangelo © Kmiragaya | Dreamstime.com
The David is perhaps Michelangelo Buonarroti’s most representative sculptural work, his most famous masterpiece, created when he was not yet 30 years old. The brief history of this work is truly compelling.
A large block of white marble, purchased in the mid-1500s by the Opera di Santa Maria del Fiore, sat unused for decades after Agostino di Duccio and Antonio Rossellino attempted to carve a David out of it, but without success. The marble, nicknamed“the giant,” was fragile and damaged, probably by water infiltration.
In 1501, the 26-year-old Michelangelo was commissioned to complete it and sculpted it in the courtyards of the Opera del Duomo, achieving an extraordinary feat: a colossal statue carved from a single imperfect block.
Completed in 1504, Michelangelo’s David aroused such admiration that a committee of great artists, including Leonardo da Vinci, decided to place it in front of the Palazzo Vecchio, in Piazza della Signoria-the political heart of Florence-and not on the outer buttresses of the cathedral, so that everyone could admire it at all times.
And that was its placement until 1873, when the statue was moved to the Accademia Gallery, where it still stands today. The Museo dell’Opera del Duomo, in fact, had not yet been established.
The St. Matthew

photo via Wikipedia
In 1503, as the David was nearing completion and it was now clear to all that it would be a masterpiece, the Opera del Duomo entrusted Michelangelo with an immensely prestigious commission: the creation of 12 monumental statues of the Apostles, intended for the pillars under Brunelleschi’s dome.
The artist was supposed to make one a year but, now famous and disputed, he interrupted the contract in 1505 to move to Rome, called by Pope Julius II.
He left Florence with only the St. Matthew. The statue, more than two meters high, is unfinished, but despite this it is considered an absolute masterpiece. What is striking is the figure’s expressive force: the apostle seems to struggle to free himself from the block of marble, a prime example of Michelangelo’s “unfinished” technique.
Later, the commission of the Apostles was given to other sculptors (such as Sansovino and Bandinelli) and today those statues can be seen inside the Duomo.
The St. Matthew remained at the Opera del Duomo for about three centuries, until 1874, when it was transferred to the Accademia Gallery along with the David and the Prisoners. Had the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo already existed (it was opened only in 1891), the work would probably have remained there in its original context.
The Bandini Pietà

File ID 345768543 | Michelangelo © Ramon Ivan Moreno Prieto | Dreamstime.com
The Bandini Pietà was not made in Florence, but in Rome, and was intended for the funeral monument Michelangelo was designing for himself. Yet, it is the only sculpture by Buonarroti to be housed in the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo.
Unlike the other two pietas (the Vaticana and the Rondanini), where only the Virgin Mary is depicted in the act of supporting the body of Christ, the Bandini also features the figures of Mary Magdalene and Nicodemus, in whose face Michelangelo authoritatively portrayed his image of an old and tired man.
Buonarroti began the work in 1547, only to leave it unfinished after trying to destroy it. Thus, in 1555, he gave it to his servant Antonio da Casteldurante, who commissioned Tiberio Calcagni to reassemble the fragments.
The work passed to the banker Francesco Bandini, then to Cardinal Luigi Capponi and, in 1671, was purchased by Cosimo III de’ Medici. After a complex transport from Rome to Florence, it remained for about fifty years in the basement of the Basilica of San Lorenzo.
In 1722 it was placed in the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore, and since 1981 it has found its current location in the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo, in the center of the room entitled “Michelangelo’s Tribune.”
Michelangelo and his Duomo

File ID 51439200 | © Kiba Liliya | Dreamstime.com
Beyond the works he commissioned and actually completed, Michelangelo had a very deep and passionate relationship with the Florence Cathedral complex.
This is evidenced by his words, now of praise now of criticism, which forever changed the perception of some monuments:
- The Gate of Paradise: It was Buonarroti himself who coined this name for the golden door of the Baptistery of San Giovanni, declaring that it was so beautiful that it could stand at the entrance to heaven.
- The Dome’s “Gabbione”: In contrast, he panned the gallery built by Baccio d’Agnolo on Brunelleschi’s Dome, dismissively calling it a “cricket cage.” His judgment was so authoritative that work was halted and the gallery remained unfinished on seven of its eight sides.
However, it is equally interesting to ask not only what the Duomo and its monumental complex represented for Michelangelo, but more importantly the opposite.
The lapidary judgments

File ID 113498614 © Aleksandra Lande | Dreamstime.com
Michelangelo did not have an accommodating nature. He was introverted, undiplomatic, and if he had to express an opinion, he did not hide behind acrobatic turns of phrase. For better or for worse.
Thus, when he judged the gilded portal for the Baptistery of San Giovanni, created by Lorenzo Ghiberti with the collaboration of his son Vittore, he literally spoke of the “Gate of Paradise.” This masterpiece of the Florentine Renaissance, whose original panels are preserved in the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo, is universally known by this definition.
“Cage for crickets,” on the other hand, is the lapidary comment with which Michelangelo rejected the balcony of the Dome, made by Baccio d’Agnolo, considering it too modest and “petty” in size for such an imposing work.
A judgment that decreed the final halt of the work. He would have done it differently: in the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo you can see a wooden model of the gallery attributed precisely to Buonarroti, which testifies to his alternative vision for completing the drum of the Dome.
The influence of Brunelleschi and Donatello
Despite his two prolonged Roman periods, Buonarroti never cut the umbilical cord with his adopted city, Florence. And when he found himself designing the Dome of St. Peter’s Basilica, his technical and architectural model was precisely the Dome of Santa Maria del Fiore.
Buonarroti made “his dome” by taking up the idea of the double dome, ribs and summit lantern with which Brunelleschi changed the aerial profile of Florence forever. It is said that on leaving for Rome he wrote, “I go to Rome to make her sister, of her greater, but not of her more beautiful.”
Michelangelo was also deeply inspired by the 15th-century sculptures in the Duomo and Campanile, particularly Donatello: his famous Moses clearly recalls the St. John the Evangelist.
Michelangelo’s David is also inspired by Nanni di Banco‘sIsaiah. Even the Christ Judge of the Last Judgment in the Sistine Chapel seems to relate back to the powerful mosaics of the Florentine Baptistery, which Michelangelo observed as a child.
FAQ
Originally Yes. The statue was supposed to find placei in one of the buttresses of the Duomo. However, the work proved to be of such beauty and artistic value that a commission, which included Leonardo da Vinci, decided to place Michelangelo’s David in Piazza della Signoria.
This is the Bandini Pietà, a sculptural group that Michelangelo sculpted in Rome and thought for his own funeral monument, so much so that the artist self-portrayed the face of Nicodemus.
There is a close connection between Michelangelo and Florence Cathedral. The great artist was inspired by Brunelleschi’s ideas to create the Dome of St. Peter’s in Rome, while Donatello’s 15th-century statues in the Duomo and Baptistery provided a model for Buonarroti’s sculptural style.
The work was actually intended for his own funeral monument, and Michelangelo began sculpting it while working in Rome. The marble group passed from hand to hand and was transported to Florence nearly a century after the great artist’s death.
Unfortunately, no. Michelangelo had been commissioned to make monumental statues of the 12 apostles, but Buonarroti only made (and did not even complete) the St. Matthew that you can see at the Accademia Gallery.
Conclusions
Although living his last years in Rome, where he died, Michelangelo always remained connected to Florence, and his intense relationship with the Cathedral, the heart of the city, is a clear testimony to this.
It was a relationship made up of genius, unfinished works, sharp judgments and the inspiration derived from confrontation with artists and masterpieces that forever influenced his style, his vision of art and the world.
Florence, for its part, never forgot its brilliant son. Just think of the daring abduction of his body and the adventurous transport on a cart to the Basilica of Santa Croce, where Michelangelo finally rests. Perhaps.
